Fake Cartier Watch vs Real: How to Tell the Difference


Cartier, the renowned French luxury brand, has been crafting exquisite timepieces for over a century. However, the brand's popularity has also made it a target for counterfeiters, who produce fake Cartier watches that can deceive unsuspecting buyers.

In this article, we'll explore the key differences between genuine Cartier watches and their counterfeit counterparts. We'll examine various aspects of the watch, including the case, weight, engravings, dial, glass, and signature features. Additionally, we'll discuss the importance of checking the serial number, considering the cost, and purchasing from a trusted seller. 

By the end of this article, you'll have a comprehensive understanding of how to distinguish between a fake Cartier watch and a genuine one. Armed with this knowledge, you can make informed decisions when purchasing a Cartier timepiece, ensuring that you invest in an authentic piece of luxury.

Case and Screws

cartier case and screws

The case and screws of a watch can provide significant clues about its authenticity. Genuine Cartier watches are known for their exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail. The cases are precisely machined from high-quality materials, resulting in a flawless finish that showcases the brand's commitment to excellence.

One of the most telling signs of a genuine Cartier watch is the alignment and uniformity of the screws. Cartier takes great care to ensure that each screw is perfectly positioned and tightened, creating a harmonious and balanced appearance. The screws should be evenly spaced and sit flush with the surface of the case, without any gaps or protrusions.

In contrast, fake Cartier watches often have poorly finished or misaligned screws. The screws may be of varying sizes, unevenly spaced, or not flush with the case. Some counterfeit watches may even have screws that are merely decorative and do not actually function. 

When examining the case and screws of a Cartier watch, take the time to scrutinize the details closely. Look for any inconsistencies, rough edges, or signs of poor craftsmanship. A genuine Cartier watch will have a flawless finish and precise attention to detail, while a fake may have telltale signs of inferior quality.

Weight of Watch

Cartier Weight of Watch

Another important factor to consider when determining the authenticity of a Cartier watch is its weight. Genuine Cartier watches are crafted from premium materials, such as gold, platinum, or high-grade stainless steel. These materials contribute to the substantial weight of the watch, which is a key indicator of its quality and authenticity.

When you hold a genuine Cartier watch in your hand, you'll notice that it has a satisfying heft to it. The weight of the watch should feel balanced and proportional to its size. This is because Cartier uses only the finest materials in the construction of their timepieces, ensuring that each watch meets their rigorous standards for quality and durability.

In contrast, counterfeit Cartier watches are often made with cheaper, lower-quality materials. These materials may include lightweight alloys, plated metals, or even plastic components. As a result, fake Cartier watches tend to feel significantly lighter than their genuine counterparts.

To assess the weight of a Cartier watch, it can be helpful to compare it to a known genuine example of the same model. If you have the opportunity to handle both watches, pay attention to the difference in weight between the two. A fake Cartier watch will likely feel noticeably lighter and less substantial than the authentic version. 

Keep in mind that the weight of a watch varies slightly depending on the specific model and materials used. However, a significant discrepancy in weight is a strong indication that the watch may be a counterfeit.

Case Back Engraving

Cartier Case Back Engraving

The case back of a Cartier watch is another crucial area to examine when determining its authenticity. Genuine Cartier watches feature engravings on the case back that are crisp, clean, and precisely executed. These engravings typically include the Cartier logo, model information, serial number, and various hallmarks or certifications.

When inspecting the case back engraving, pay close attention to the quality and clarity of the text and logos. Authentic Cartier engravings are sharp and well-defined, with consistent line thickness and spacing. The letters should be evenly sized and properly aligned, without any signs of blurring, unevenness, or misspellings.

Counterfeit Cartier watches often have poorly executed case back engravings that lack the precision and clarity of genuine examples. The text may appear blurry, crooked, or inconsistent in size and spacing. Additionally, fake watches may feature misspellings or incorrect font styles that deviate from Cartier's official branding.

Another important aspect to consider is the depth and consistency of the engraving. Genuine Cartier engravings are typically deep and uniform, with a smooth, polished finish. Fake watches may have shallow or uneven engravings that appear rough or unfinished. 

When examining the case back engraving, it's also essential to verify the information provided. Check that the model name, serial number, and any other details match the specifications of the genuine Cartier watch. If any of the information seems incorrect or inconsistent, it may be a sign that the watch is counterfeit.

Dial

Cartier Dial

The dial of a Cartier watch is a critical component that showcases the brand's meticulous attention to detail and commitment to quality. Genuine Cartier dials are characterized by their precise printing, well-defined markers, and the iconic Roman numerals that have become synonymous with the brand.

When examining the dial of a Cartier watch, pay close attention to the quality and consistency of the printing. Authentic Cartier dials feature crisp, evenly spaced text and numerals that are perfectly aligned and proportional. The printing should be sharp and legible, without any signs of blurring, smudging, or inconsistencies.

One of the most recognizable features of a Cartier dial is the use of Roman numerals. These numerals should be expertly crafted, with clean lines and precise serifs. Each numeral should be evenly spaced and properly aligned, creating a harmonious and balanced overall appearance. In some cases, Cartier watches may feature a combination of Roman numerals and stick markers, depending on the specific model

Counterfeit Cartier watches often have dials that fail to meet the exacting standards of the genuine article. The printing may appear blurry, inconsistent, or misaligned, with numerals and markers that are not properly spaced or proportioned. The Roman numerals may have incorrect shapes or sizes, or they may be printed using a font that doesn't match Cartier's official typeface.

Another aspect to consider when examining the dial is the quality of the hands. Genuine Cartier watches feature hands that are finely crafted and properly proportioned to the dial. The hands should have a smooth, polished finish and move smoothly around the dial. Fake watches may have hands that are poorly finished, bent, or do not align correctly with the markers.

Scratch-Proof Glass

Cartier Scratch-Proof Glass

One of the hallmarks of a genuine Cartier watch is the use of high-quality, scratch-resistant sapphire crystal glass. This feature not only enhances the durability of the watch but also contributes to its overall luxury and refinement. When examining a Cartier watch, it's essential to assess the quality and condition of the glass to determine its authenticity.

Authentic Cartier watches are equipped with sapphire crystal glass, which is known for its exceptional hardness and resistance to scratches. Sapphire crystal is a synthetic material that ranks second only to diamond in terms of hardness on the Mohs scale. This means that genuine Cartier watch glass is highly unlikely to scratch under normal wear conditions, maintaining its clarity and brilliance over time.

When inspecting the glass of a Cartier watch, look closely for any signs of scratches, chips, or cracks. A genuine Cartier watch should have a flawless, unblemished surface that reflects light beautifully. If the glass appears scratched or damaged, it may indicate that the watch is a counterfeit or has been subjected to excessive wear.

Counterfeit Cartier watches often use inferior glass materials, such as mineral crystal or even plastic, which are far more susceptible to scratches and damage. These materials may initially appear similar to sapphire crystal, but they will quickly accumulate scratches and scuffs with regular use, diminishing the overall appearance and value of the watch.

To test the quality of the glass, you can gently run your fingernail or a soft cloth across the surface. Sapphire crystal will feel smooth and resistant, while inferior materials may feel softer or more prone to scratching. However, be cautious when performing this test, as applying excessive pressure could potentially damage the glass, even on a genuine Cartier watch.

Signature Blue Cabochon

Cartier Signature Blue Cabochon gemstone set into the crown

One of the most iconic and recognizable features of many Cartier watches is the signature blue cabochon gemstone set into the crown. This distinctive element has become a symbol of Cartier's elegance and refinement, and it serves as an important indicator of a watch's authenticity. 

The blue cabochon is typically made from sapphire, a precious gemstone known for its durability and vibrant color. Cartier carefully selects each cabochon for its watches, ensuring that the gemstone meets their exacting standards for quality and beauty. The cabochon is precisely cut and polished to achieve a smooth, rounded shape that catches the light and adds a subtle touch of luxury to the watch.

When examining the blue cabochon on a Cartier watch, pay close attention to its appearance and setting. On a genuine Cartier watch, the cabochon should be well-cut and polished, with a consistent color and clarity throughout. The blue hue should be deep and saturated, without any visible inclusions or blemishes. 

The cabochon should also be securely set into the crown, with no gaps or visible adhesive. The setting should be precise and clean, showcasing the gemstone's beauty without any signs of poor craftsmanship or damage.

In contrast, fake Cartier watches often feature low-quality imitations of the blue cabochon. These may be made from inferior materials, such as glass or plastic, and may lack the vivid color and clarity of a genuine sapphire. The cut and polish of the cabochon may also be subpar, resulting in a dull or asymmetrical appearance.

Counterfeit watches may also have poorly executed cabochon settings, with visible gaps, glue, or other signs of shoddy workmanship. In some cases, the cabochon may be missing altogether, or it may be set crooked or off-center.

Check the Serial Number

Cartier Serial Number

When investigating the authenticity of a Cartier watch, one of the most important steps is to check the serial number. Every genuine Cartier watch is assigned a unique serial number that serves as a key identifier and helps to track the watch's production and distribution history. By verifying the serial number, you can gain valuable insights into the watch's legitimacy and origins.

On most Cartier watches, the serial number is engraved on the back of the case. The engraving should be clear, precise, and well-defined, without any signs of tampering or alteration. The serial number typically consists of a combination of letters and numbers, and its format may vary depending on the specific model and year of production.

To verify the authenticity of a Cartier watch using the serial number, you can contact Cartier directly or consult with an authorized Cartier dealer. Provide them with the serial number, and they will be able to confirm whether the watch is indeed a genuine Cartier timepiece. This process can also help you determine the watch's production date, place of origin, and any relevant service history.

When examining the serial number, be cautious of watches that have no serial number at all or feature a suspiciously worn or altered engraving. Counterfeit Cartier watches may have fake or missing serial numbers, or the numbers may not match the format used by Cartier for that specific model and year.

It's also important to note that while checking the serial number is a crucial step in verifying authenticity, it should be used in conjunction with other methods of authentication. Counterfeiters have become increasingly sophisticated in their techniques, and some fake watches may feature convincing serial number engravings.

Cost

Cost Cartier

When considering looking to purchase a Cartier watch, it's a good idea to be mindful of  how much is a Cartier watch. Genuine Cartier watches are luxury timepieces that command premium prices due to their exceptional quality, craftsmanship, and brand reputation. If a deal seems too good to be true, it likely involves a counterfeit watch.

Cartier watches are manufactured using the finest materials and are subject to rigorous quality control standards. The brand invests heavily in research and development, ensuring that each watch meets their exact specifications for precision, durability, and aesthetics. As a result, authentic Cartier watches are priced accordingly, reflecting the time, effort, and resources that go into their creation.

When shopping for a Cartier watch, be cautious of heavily discounted prices or "bargain" deals from unknown or unreliable sellers. Counterfeiters often use low prices as a tactic to lure unsuspecting buyers, promising authentic Cartier watches at a fraction of the retail cost. However, these watches are typically low-quality imitations that fail to meet Cartier's standards for excellence.

It's important to research the current market prices for the specific Cartier model you're interested in. Compare prices from authorized Cartier dealers and reputable pre-owned watch specialists to get a sense of the expected price range. Keep in mind that prices may vary slightly based on factors such as the watch's condition, age, and any included accessories or documentation.

If you encounter a Cartier watch that is significantly cheaper than the prevailing market price, it's a strong indication that the watch may be counterfeit. While it's possible to find legitimate used Cartier watches at slightly reduced prices, be wary of any deal that seems unrealistic or too good to be true.

Buy From a Trusted Seller

Buy Cartier Watches From a Trusted Seller

One of the most effective ways to ensure that you're purchasing a genuine Cartier watch is to buy from a trusted seller. By dealing with reputable sources, you can minimize the risk of falling victim to counterfeiters and have greater confidence in the authenticity of your timepiece.

The safest option is to purchase your Cartier watch directly from an authorized Cartier boutique or a reputable pre-owned Cartier dealer. These establishments sell only genuine Cartier products. When buying from an authorized dealer, you'll have access to the full range of the current Cartier watches but likely will not be able to shop discontinued models.

If you're considering purchasing a used Cartier watch, it's essential to deal with a reputable seller who specializes in authentic luxury timepieces. Look for established pre-owned watch retailers with a proven track record of selling genuine Cartier watches. These sellers often have extensive knowledge of the brand and employ experts who can thoroughly authenticate each watch before offering it for sale.

When buying online, be cautious of sellers with limited or no feedback, or those offering prices that seem suspiciously low. Stick to well-known, trusted platforms and sellers with a history of positive reviews and satisfied customers. If possible, try to see the watch in person before making a purchase, as this will allow you to inspect its quality and authenticity firsthand.

Regardless of where you choose to buy your Cartier watch, always request documentation that verifies the watch's authenticity. This may include a valid warranty card, a certificate of authenticity, or an official sales receipt from an authorized Cartier dealer. Reputable sellers will be happy to provide these documents and answer any questions you may have about the watch's history and provenance.

Examples of Fake Cartier Watches

Examples of Fake Cartier Watches

To better understand the differences between genuine and counterfeit Cartier watches, it's helpful to examine some specific examples of fake timepieces. By familiarizing yourself with the common flaws and inconsistencies found in counterfeit watches, you'll be better equipped to spot a fake Cartier watch and make an informed purchasing decision.

One of the most counterfeited Cartier models is the Cartier Tank series. Fake Tank watches often feature incorrect proportions, with cases that are either too thick or too thin compared to the genuine article. The dial may also have incorrect markings or typography, such as misaligned or poorly printed Roman numerals. The cabochon on the crown may be the wrong color or shape, or it may be missing altogether.

Another popular target for counterfeiters is the Cartier Santos series. Fake Santos watches may have poorly finished cases with rough edges or uneven brushing. The bezel screws, a distinctive feature of the Santos design, may be incorrectly sized or positioned. The dial may feature incorrect fonts or logos, and the hands may be the wrong shape or size.

The Cartier Ballon Bleu series is also frequently counterfeited. Fake Ballon Bleu watches may have incorrect case shapes or proportions, with bezels that are too wide or too narrow. The blue cabochon on the crown may be the wrong shade of blue or have visible flaws or inclusions. The dial may have incorrect markings or a poorly executed guilloche pattern.

When examining any Cartier watch, pay close attention to the overall quality of the craftsmanship. Genuine Cartier watches are known for their exceptional attention to detail and flawless finishes. Counterfeit watches, on the other hand, often have visible flaws or inconsistencies that betray their illegitimate origins.

So, How to Tell if a Cartier Watch is Real?

In summary, when determining the authenticity of a Cartier watch, consider the following key points:

  1. Examine the case, screws, and case back engravings for precision and clarity.
  2. Assess the weight and quality of materials used.
  3. Inspect the dial, glass, and cabochon for accuracy and craftsmanship.
  4. Verify the serial number with Cartier or an authorized dealer.
  5. Be cautious of prices that seem too good to be true.
  6. Purchase from trusted sellers and be aware of common counterfeit examples.

By following these guidelines and maintaining a discerning eye, you can significantly reduce the risk of purchasing a counterfeit Cartier watch. If you have any doubts, consult with a trusted expert.

Investing in a genuine Cartier watch ensures that you're receiving the quality, craftsmanship, and legacy that the brand represents. Thorough research and education will enable you to make a confident and informed decision when purchasing your Cartier timepiece.

About Bob's Watches Editorial

Paul AltieriWith over two decades of experience in the luxury watch industry, the Bob's Watches Editorial Team stands at the forefront of watch expertise and insight. Our team, composed of seasoned watch enthusiasts, skilled horologists, and knowledgeable industry insiders, is dedicated to bringing you the latest and most accurate information in the world of luxury timepieces. We pride ourselves on our meticulous attention to detail and our unwavering commitment to authenticity. Our editorial content is a reflection of our passion for luxury watches and our dedication to providing our readers with comprehensive, unbiased, and up-to-date information. Our expertise spans a wide range of topics, including in-depth reviews of the latest models, historical retrospectives of iconic timepieces, and insightful analyses of market trends. We are also renowned for our detailed guides on watch maintenance and investment advice, making us a trusted resource for both seasoned collectors and new enthusiasts alike. As thought leaders in the watch industry, we understand the importance of staying ahead of the curve. That's why we continually update our knowledge and skills, ensuring that our readers receive the most current and relevant information. Whether you're seeking advice on your next luxury watch purchase or looking to deepen your understanding of watch craftsmanship, the Bob's Watches Editorial Team is here to guide you.

Table of Contents